Notes From Flyover Country

Friday, May 18, 2012

What's a Trillion Dollars Among Friends? Is Student-Loan Debt "Good Debt"?


A couple of days ago, Beckie Supiano wrote an article for Chronicle of Higher Education, entitled “What Does $1-Trillion in Student Debt Really Mean? Maybe Not That Much,” which suggested that the nation's massive student-loan debt is no big deal.  Some of the people cited in Supiano’s article apparently believe that student-loan indebtedness is fundamentally different from the home-mortgage crisis because education, unlike a mortgaged home, has intrinsic value that does not diminish over time.

For example, Anthony P. Carnevale, director of Georgetown University's Center on Education and the Workforce, described student-loan debt as "good debt". In fact, Carnevale maintained, “This is exactly the kind of debt a society wants.” 

Mr. Carnevale’s perspective on student loans would be correct if all students received good value when they borrowed money to obtain a college education. But, as everyone knows, millions of people have borrowed money to pursue post-secondary education and did not see their lives improve in any meaningful way.  A person who borrows $100,000 to obtain a degree in religious studies, winds up working as a waitress, and defaults on her student loans does not have the kind of debt society wants. That kind of debt is not “good debt”.

Furthermore, contrary to some of the views expressed in the Supiano article, the student-loan crisis is very similar to the home-mortgage crisis. In fact, student loans have probably caused more human suffering than the home-mortgage meltdown.  People who own homes worth less than their mortgages are certainly under stress. But at least these people have roofs over their heads, and they own tangible assets. Furthermore, home-mortgage holders who are financially unable to pay their monthly mortgage payments can discharge their mortgages in bankruptcy.

In contrast, people who took out student loans to obtain a college education did not obtain anything tangible except their diplomas, and many did not receive the skills or training from their experience that would enable them to obtain good-paying jobs or otherwise improve their lives.  Many people who borrowed substantial amounts of money to obtain degrees in such fields as art history, religious studies, sociology and anthropology are in real financial trouble because they can’t find employment that compensates them enough to pay off their student loans.

Furthermore, unlike homeowners who have unmanageable mortgages, most overburdened student-loan debtors cannot discharge their loans in bankruptcy.  Although they can obtain deferments on their loan payments if they can show economic hardship, interest on their loans will continue to accrue in most instances, increasing the size of their debt

In short, to suggest that the nation’s $1 trillion in accumulated student-loan debt is not a serious problem shows a profound lack of understanding about the tremendous suffering that millions of student-loan debtors are experiencing. There are lots of things we can do to get the student-loan crisis under control, but we should begin by providing meaningful relief to overburdened student-loan debtors who have no reasonable prospect of ever paying off their student loans.

References

Supiano, B. (2012, May 16). What Does $1-Trillion in Student Debt Really Mean? Maybe Not That Much. Chronicle of Higher Education. http://chronicle.com/article/What-Does-1-Trillion-Mean-/131900/?key=TWwidAI8byUVbHBhYDpAbj4AaH0%2BMUp2YydBPX4rblpXGQ%3D%3D.



Posted by Richard Fossey at 12:34 PM
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Labels: Anthony P. Carnevale, Beckie Supiano, Center on Education and the Workforce, student-loan debt, What does $1-Trillion in Student Debt Really Mean

No comments:

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

The Dixie Apocalpse

The Dixie Apocalpse
Click to order and learn more on Amazon

Essays about Texas

  • Should Texas reaffirm its status as an independent nation?

Follow by Email!

Get new posts by email:

About Me

My photo
Richard Fossey
Richard Fossey is a professor emeritus at the University of Louisiana in Lafayette, Louisiana. He received his law degree from the University of Texas and his doctorate from Harvard Graduate School of Education. He is the author of The Dixie Apocalypse, a dystopian novel set in Louisiana and Texas.
View my complete profile

Blog Archive

  • ►  2025 (86)
    • ►  June (8)
    • ►  May (9)
    • ►  April (18)
    • ►  March (17)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (11)
  • ►  2024 (109)
    • ►  December (13)
    • ►  November (6)
    • ►  October (6)
    • ►  September (11)
    • ►  August (8)
    • ►  July (12)
    • ►  June (15)
    • ►  May (3)
    • ►  April (8)
    • ►  March (9)
    • ►  February (11)
    • ►  January (7)
  • ►  2023 (64)
    • ►  December (3)
    • ►  November (3)
    • ►  October (4)
    • ►  September (8)
    • ►  August (4)
    • ►  July (5)
    • ►  June (6)
    • ►  May (12)
    • ►  April (3)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ►  February (5)
    • ►  January (7)
  • ►  2022 (94)
    • ►  December (6)
    • ►  November (12)
    • ►  October (6)
    • ►  September (12)
    • ►  August (10)
    • ►  July (13)
    • ►  June (8)
    • ►  May (4)
    • ►  April (5)
    • ►  March (6)
    • ►  February (6)
    • ►  January (6)
  • ►  2021 (106)
    • ►  December (11)
    • ►  November (11)
    • ►  October (10)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (6)
    • ►  July (14)
    • ►  June (9)
    • ►  May (7)
    • ►  April (5)
    • ►  March (7)
    • ►  February (4)
    • ►  January (18)
  • ►  2020 (123)
    • ►  December (16)
    • ►  November (10)
    • ►  October (8)
    • ►  September (3)
    • ►  August (12)
    • ►  July (11)
    • ►  June (12)
    • ►  May (13)
    • ►  April (15)
    • ►  March (11)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (9)
  • ►  2019 (89)
    • ►  December (6)
    • ►  November (5)
    • ►  October (11)
    • ►  September (7)
    • ►  August (12)
    • ►  July (9)
    • ►  June (3)
    • ►  May (4)
    • ►  April (8)
    • ►  March (10)
    • ►  February (9)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ►  2018 (84)
    • ►  December (8)
    • ►  November (7)
    • ►  October (5)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (8)
    • ►  July (10)
    • ►  June (9)
    • ►  May (10)
    • ►  April (3)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ►  February (4)
    • ►  January (12)
  • ►  2017 (147)
    • ►  December (8)
    • ►  November (11)
    • ►  October (13)
    • ►  September (10)
    • ►  August (9)
    • ►  July (9)
    • ►  June (15)
    • ►  May (18)
    • ►  April (15)
    • ►  March (11)
    • ►  February (12)
    • ►  January (16)
  • ►  2016 (146)
    • ►  December (11)
    • ►  November (7)
    • ►  October (8)
    • ►  September (11)
    • ►  August (15)
    • ►  July (12)
    • ►  June (13)
    • ►  May (14)
    • ►  April (17)
    • ►  March (16)
    • ►  February (10)
    • ►  January (12)
  • ►  2015 (65)
    • ►  December (13)
    • ►  November (10)
    • ►  October (13)
    • ►  September (7)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  May (2)
    • ►  April (6)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (2)
  • ►  2014 (66)
    • ►  December (3)
    • ►  November (6)
    • ►  October (3)
    • ►  September (11)
    • ►  August (4)
    • ►  July (2)
    • ►  June (12)
    • ►  May (8)
    • ►  April (6)
    • ►  March (2)
    • ►  February (2)
    • ►  January (7)
  • ►  2013 (66)
    • ►  December (10)
    • ►  November (12)
    • ►  October (9)
    • ►  September (10)
    • ►  August (11)
    • ►  July (8)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  February (1)
  • ▼  2012 (35)
    • ►  December (1)
    • ►  November (5)
    • ►  October (3)
    • ►  September (2)
    • ►  August (1)
    • ►  July (2)
    • ►  June (3)
    • ▼  May (7)
      • Today’s New York Times Editorial About Student Loa...
      • President Obama Can Do ThreeThings Right Now To Sh...
      • Higher Education Industry to Students: If You Are ...
      • What's a Trillion Dollars Among Friends? Is Studen...
      • What should a university do when its employees att...
      • The Controversy Over Elizabeth Warren’s Native Ame...
      • A Crummy Idea: Supplementing University Presidents...
    • ►  April (10)
    • ►  March (1)

Popular Posts

  • Student-loan debtors beware: Congressman Tom Garrett wants your Social Security check
  • University of Phoenix graduate got her student loans discharged on the grounds that Phoenix falsely certified she was eligible to receive the loans
  • Student Loans, Bankruptcy, and Creditors' Lawyers: If Auschwitz Comes to the United States, Will Attorneys Handle the Paperwork?
  • Barney Frank, World Class Sleaze, Accuses Bernie Sanders of McCarthyism
  • Emigrate! To Avoid Becoming Sharecroppers, Some Young People Will Leave the United States to Escape Student Loan Debt
  • Good News out of Kansas: A compassionate bankruptcy judge grants a 59-year-old debtor a partial discharge of her student loans
  • Suicide and Student Loans: Is There a Link?
  • Educational Credit Management Corporation is a bad actor: Rafael Pardo's article about ECMC's litigation misbehavior
  • Betsy DeVos should resign as Education Secretary and Trump should replace her with a junkyard dog
  • Educational Credit Management Corporation makes good money chasing destitute student-loan debtors: The Obama Administration should take action

Follow me

Follow me
Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.