Tuesday, December 22, 2015

The Department of Education's Lynn Mahaffie wrote a disingenuous letter outlining when the Department of Education will not oppose bankruptcy discharge for student-loan debtors under the Undue Hardship rule

The Department of Education's Lynn Mahaffie issued a letter last July outlining when DOE and its debt collectors will not oppose bankruptcy discharge for student-loan debtors.  In fact, Mahaffie's letter is disingenuous.

Reading Mahaffie's letter, you might think DOE and its debt-collecting lackeys would not oppose a bankruptcy discharge for student-loan debtors who are in truly distressing circumstances or when it would be pointless to try to collect the debt. But you would be wrong.

In fact, DOE and its debt collectors oppose bankruptcy discharge for nearly everyone.

Here are some examples:

In Myhre v. Department of Education, DOE opposed bankruptcy discharge for a quadriplegic student-loan debtor who was working almost full time but could not make enough money to pay his living expenses, including the cost of a full-time caregiver.

In Roth v. Educational Credit Management Corporation, ECMC, perhaps DOE's most ruthless debt collector, opposed a bankruptcy discharge for a 68-year-old woman with chronic health issues who was living on a Social Security check of less than $800 a month.

In Abney v. U.S. Department of Education, decided after Mahaffie's letter was issued, DOE opposed a bankruptcy discharge for a man living on less than $1200 a month and who rode a bicycle to work because he couldn't afford a car.  This poor guy was making child-support payments that almost equaled his take-home pay and had lost his home to foreclosure. In fact, this man's situation was so desperate that he lived for a time in the cab of one of his employer's trucks. And DOE demanded that he be put in a 25-year repayment plan!

Mahaffie's letter listed several factors for determining when to oppose a student-loan debtor's bankruptcy discharge, including the debtor's age and health status. But DOE is garnishing the Social Security checks of 150,000 elderly people and fighting bankruptcy relief without regard to a student-loan debtor's health status. Hey, if DOE fights bankruptcy discharge for a quadriplegic, it fights it for everyone.

And Mayaffie also indicated that DOE and student-loan creditors wouldn't fight bankruptcy discharge if litigation costs outweighed the likely benefits. But in Kelly v. Educational Credit Management Corporation, ECMC chased a student-loan debtor through the federal courts for seven years!

Frankly, Mahaffie's letter is insincere. Contrary to the representations in her letter, the Department of Education and Educational Credit Management Corporation fight nearly every student-loan bankruptcy with almost desperate ferocity.  It knows that millions of people are entitled to bankruptcy relief from their student-loan debt under standards being laid down by compassionate bankruptcy courts. And it knows if student-loan debtors start getting the relief to which they are entitled under basic principles of fairness and justice, the student loan program will collapse.

Picture of Lynn Mahaffie, Deputy Assistant Secy for Policy, Planning and Innovation, U.S. Dept of Education
Lynn Mahaffie, J.D.
DOE's Deputy Assistant Secretary wrote a disingenous letter


Lynn Mahaffie, Undue Hardship Discharge of Title IV Loans in Bankruptcy Adversary Proceedings. CL ID: GEN 15-13, July 7, 2015. 

Myhre v. U.S. Department of Education, 503 B.R. 698 (Bakr. W.D. Wis. 2013).

Roth v. Educational Credit Management Corporation, 490 B.R. 908 (9th Cir. BAP 2013).


  1. Another fine post! Steve Rhode (Get-Out-of-Debt-Guy) also wrote about Abney v. DOE and the the court's decision to NOT force this debtor into an IBRP and granted a discharge under 11 USC §523(a)(8). Rhode's blog is here:https://getoutofdebt.org/97661/bankruptcy-court-tells-dept-ed-go-shove-ibr-unrealalistic

  2. This reads like the worst horror story imaginable. Why? Because this is really happening to people! I for one keep writing questions to the worthless Presidential race candidates and haven't had one of them asked during their absurd debate freakshow. I think people are going to have to do what we do best and hurt the economy.

    Stay home and do nothing. What happens when Americans go on strike? I'm curious to find out.

  3. Excellent piece again, Richard!!

  4. The superb highly informative blog I’m about to share this with all my contacts.

  5. The article is really amazing and entertaining for all those seeking fun and entertainment. The articles and such posts regarding Watch A Hollywood Christmas in UK and other shows are really entertaining for everyone.

  6. It's disappointing that education has become more of a business than a means of enablement, and students face the brunt of it. I think it's essential for more people to be aware of the situation and the obstacles students face when trying to discharge loans. Some Top Dissertation Writing Services like The Academic Papers UK are raising awareness about student loans through bankruptcy.

  7. If you are looking for "digital marketing services near me," it's essential to choose a company that understands the latest trends and strategies in the field. With the right team, you can create a comprehensive digital marketing campaign that will help you reach your target audience and achieve your goals.

  8. If you are looking for a motorcycle accident lawyer, who can provide you a legal advice and reduce the charges against you. Create an appointment if you need any legal advice. motorcycle accident attorneys

  9. In New York, getting through a divorce requires a few processes. First, a summons and complaint detailing the reasons for divorce are filed by one party. In response, the other side divulges financial data. It might be required to hold a court hearing if the issues are not resolved. In the end, the divorce is finalized when the court renders a decision. Recall that getting legal counsel can make things easier. What is The Process of Divorce in New York

  10. A Winchester traffic lawyer assists clients facing traffic violations, Winchester traffic lawyer providing legal expertise to challenge charges, reduce penalties, Winchester traffic lawyer and navigate the legal process to achieve the best possible outcome.

  11. Embarking on a journey to learn a new language is an enriching experience that opens doors to endless opportunities. With the IGL German Language Course in Karachi, you can embark on this adventure with confidence, knowing that you're in capable hands. From competitive fees to expert instruction and a comprehensive curriculum, the IGL course equips you with the tools you need to succeed in your German language endeavors.

  12. Experiential Learning and Cultural Immersion:
    Beyond the classroom, the IGL German Language Institute offers a myriad of opportunities for experiential learning and cultural immersion. From film screenings and guest lectures to study tours and exchange programs, students have access to a rich tapestry of cultural experiences that complement their language learning journey.

  13. Financial Aid and Scholarships: Financing your education abroad is a significant concern for many students. IGL consultants offer insights into available scholarships, grants, and financial aid options, helping you explore avenues to fund your education cost-effectively.

    Pre-Departure Support: Transitioning to a new country can present its own set of challenges. IGL consultants provide pre-departure orientations, equipping you with essential information about accommodation, healthcare, cultural norms, and academic expectations, ensuring a smooth transition into your new academic environment.

  14. Discover a charming blog filled with captivating content and insightful musings. Dive into a world where every post offers a delightful escape. Plus, don't miss the mention of the trendy beth dutton purse, adding a touch of style to your reading experience.

  15. Small Class Sizes: Unlike overcrowded classrooms where individual attention is scarce, IGL ensures small class sizes, allowing for personalized instruction and ample opportunities for students to practice speaking.

    Cultural Immersion: Learning a language isn't just about grammar and vocabulary; it's also about understanding the culture. IGL incorporates cultural elements into their curriculum, giving students a holistic understanding of the German-speaking world.

    Flexible Schedule: Whether you're a working professional or a student, IGL offers flexible class timings to accommodate your schedule. Morning, evening, and weekend batches are available, ensuring that anyone can pursue their German language goals.

  16. The student loan crisis is a pressing issue affecting countless individuals, burdening them with financial strain long after graduation. It's crucial to address policies and support systems that alleviate this burden. In the midst of managing academic pressures, online assignment help provides relief by offering expert guidance and timely assistance. It's a valuable resource that allows students to focus on their studies and future career prospects without the added stress of overwhelming debt.