Here are the opening words of Judge Klein's Bank of America decision:
Frank Kafka lives. This automatic stay violation case reveals that he works at Bank of America.
The mirage of promised mortgage modification lured [Erick and Renee Sundquist] into a kafkaesque nightmare of stay-violating foreclosure and unlawful detainer, tardy foreclosure rescission kept secret for months, home looted while the debtors were dispossessed, emotional distress, lost income, apparent heart attack, suicide attempt, and post-traumatic stress disorder for all of which Bank of America disclaims responsibility.
Judge Klein then detailed Bank of America's offenses in detail--his opinion is 107 pages long! And at the end, Judge Klein spelled out how the punitive damages award should be apportioned:
The actual . . . damages are $1,074,581.50. The appropriate . . . punitive damages are $45,000,000.00.
The Sundquists are enjoined to deliver $40,000,000 (minus applicable taxes) to public service entities that are important in education in consumer law and deliver of legal services to consumers: National Consumer Law Center ($10,000,000.00), National Consumer Bankruptcy Rights Center ($10,000,000.00), and the five public law schools of the University of California System ($4,000,000.00).
Of course, Bank of America will appeal Judge Klein's punitive damages award, and who knows how that will go. But regardless of what happens on appeal, Judge Klein has turned a glaring spotlight on Bank of America's outrageous behavior.
And if the damages award is upheld, money will flow to entities that can help distressed debtors fight the predatory tactics of the banks. That would be a great blessing for American society.
And this brings me to Educational Credit Management Corporation, the predatory student-loan debt collector that violated the automatic stay provision of the Bankruptcy Code more than 30 times by repeatedly garnishing the wages of Kristin Bruner-Halteman, a student-loan debtor who worked for Starbucks. In a 2016 decision, Judge Harlin DeWayne Hale, a Texas bankruptcy judge, awarded Bruner-Halteman $74,000 in punitive damages for ECMC's misbehavior.
But $74,000 is a pittance for ECMC; it probably has that much cash in loose change that slipped under its couch cushions. According to a report by the Century Foundation, ECMC has $1 billion in unrestricted assets. That's billion with a B.
So--listen up distressed student-loan debtors. If you file for bankruptcy in a case opposed by ECMC and ECMC violates the Bankruptcy Code's automatic stay provision as it did in the Bruner-Halteman case, you need to ask for several million dollars in punitive damages. How about $10 million--that's only one percent of ECMC's assets.
References
Bruner-Halteman v. Educational Credit Management Corporation, Case No. 12-324-HDH-13, ADV. No. 14-03041 (Bankr. N.D. Tex. 2016).
Robert Shireman and Tariq Habash. Have Student Loan Guaranty Agencies Lost Their Way? The Century Foundation, September 29, 2016. Accessible at https://tcf.org/content/report/student-loan-guaranty-agencies-lost-way/
Sundquist v. Bank of America, Adv. Pro. No. 204-0228, Case No. 10-35624-B-13J (Bankr. E.D. Calif. March 23, 2017).
The blog with the best stuff is provoking the people to give the good remarks.
ReplyDeleteBlogger blog
We recently hired Painters Greensburg for a residential project, and we're thrilled with the results. The team was efficient, tidy, and the quality of their work exceeded our expectations. If you're in Greensburg, PA, and need painters, this is the company to choose!"
ReplyDeleteRoman Paint Pros
There are many dissertation websites from the web stay get not surprisingly recognized within the web sites. Criminal Appeals Attorney
ReplyDeletehttps://nuimagedetailva.blogspot.com/2025/06/how-to-choose-best-ceramic-coating-for.html
ReplyDeletehttps://nuimagedetailva.blogspot.com/2025/06/car-detailing-explained-what-it-really.html
https://nuimagedetailva.blogspot.com/2025/06/ppf-for-cars-discover-best-benefits.html
https://lasbespoke.blogspot.com/2025/06/best-mobile-car-detailing-services-in.html
https://lasbespoke.blogspot.com/2025/06/is-ceramic-coating-good-for-your-cars.html
https://lasbespoke.blogspot.com/2025/06/exclusive-car-cleaning-detailing.html
https://cardetailingrichmondva.blogspot.com/2025/06/how-to-wash-your-car-at-home-step-by.html
https://cardetailingrichmondva.blogspot.com/2025/06/car-interior-cleaning-proven-techniques.html
https://cardetailingrichmondva.blogspot.com/2025/06/what-is-hand-car-wash-or-car-detailing.html
https://lakelandkitchenremodeling.wordpress.com/
ReplyDeletehttps://lakeland-kitchen-remodeling.blogspot.com/
https://homeleaderrenovati.wixsite.com/kitchen-remodeling
I used to waste hours at shops for car detailing in Pasadena, but Clean Image Mobile made it easier—they bring everything to your driveway.
ReplyDeleteSalt air and road debris can really damage paint, so ppf in Virginia Beach from Nu Image Ceramic Coating and Detailing is a smart choice for long-term protection.
ReplyDeleteI recommend Keen Eyes Auto Detailing for ceramic coating in Fredericksburg VA—their work really helps protect against scratches and UV damage.
ReplyDeleteIf you need professional driveway cleaning in Surrey, I’d recommend Crystal Jet Wash. They remove oil stains, moss, and dirt without damaging the surface.
ReplyDeleteIf you want your paint protected from Texas sun and scratches, Do It Right Ceramic Coating has the best ceramic coating in Fort Worth hands down.
ReplyDeleteMichigan Mobile Detailing
ReplyDelete"Ceramic coating isn’t just hype; the depth of gloss and protection it gives is unreal."
It’s incredible how https://www.nuimagedetail.com/
ReplyDeletecan restore headlights, paint, and trim all at once.
I love how professional
ReplyDeleterestores faded trim and tires—those finishing touches really make the car pop.
Exterior https://cleanimage101.com/
ReplyDeletereally brought back the shine of my car’s paint. It looks polished and protected now
The shine and protection from a https://triplesdetailing.com/
ReplyDeleteare unmatched compared to a normal car wash.
I didn’t realize how dull my headlights had become until the https://michiganmobiledetail.com/
ReplyDeleterestored them—now they’re crystal clear.
The difference between a basic wash and full detailing is huge, and Car Detailers Richmond VA explains it perfectly on their site. I learned a lot just browsing their content.
ReplyDeleteJust had my exterior surfaces cleaned by Crystal Jet Wash, and the difference is unbelievable. They are my go-to for pressure washing in Surrey BC because of their attention to detail and professionalism.
ReplyDeleteHighly recommend Astonishing Detail to anyone serious about keeping their car protected. Their car detailing in Richmond VA services are unmatched.
ReplyDeleteChoosing a reliable bathroom remodeling contractor in Plant City FL is easier with Home Leader Renovation. Their site highlights custom designs and long-term quality that homeowners can trust.
ReplyDeleteI recently came across Astonishing Detail while searching for the best car detailing in Richmond VA, and I must say their attention to quality and long-lasting shine really stands out.
ReplyDeleteI recently came across Crystal Jet Pressure Washing, and their professional approach to exterior cleaning in Surrey really stands out. Their website makes it super easy to book services and learn more about how pressure washing can restore surfaces.
ReplyDeleteJust had my car treated at Do It Right Ceramic Coating And Detailing—the shine is unreal! The ceramic coating makes it so much easier to maintain, and the detailing service really brought my interior back to life.
ReplyDeleteJust got my car done at Nu Image Ceramic Coating And Detailing – the gloss is unreal! If you’re in Virginia Beach and want the best ceramic coating, this is the place.
ReplyDeleteJust had my car detailed by Michigan Mobile Detail—super convenient and the results were flawless. Their mobile auto detailing service in Michigan saved me hours of time. Highly recommend checking out their website for easy booking and great deals!
ReplyDeleteI recently came across Clean Image Mobile, and honestly, it’s a game-changer for keeping my car spotless. Their detailing service is professional, and the best part is you can book everything easily through their website.
ReplyDelete