Friday, April 21, 2017

Recent Navient and National Collegiate Student Loan Bankruptcy Rulings – March 2017: A Must-Read Article by Steve Rhode

If you are overwhelmed by your student loans and thinking about filing for bankruptcy, you should read this essay by Steve Rhode. Mr. Rhode examined recent bankruptcy court adversary proceedings in which student borrowers brought complaints against Navient or National Collegiate Student Loan Trust. As Mr. Rhode relates, debtors often won significant relief in these lawsuits--sometimes through settlement agreements.

Why is Mr. Rhode's article important to you?

First, his article contains links to adversary complaints that were drafted by attorneys. If you file your own adversary complaint against your student-loan creditor, you can use these complaints as templates to file your own complaint.

Second, the proceedings Mr. Rhode examined show various theories under which debtors sought to have their loans discharged. Some of those theories might work for you.

I am frankly surprised that debtors were so successful in the cases Mr. Rhode analyzed. I wonder whether Navient and National Collegiate Student Loan Trust are more amenable to settlement than Educational Credit Management Corporation and the U.S. Department of Education. ECMC and the Department of Education have opposed bankruptcy relief in a multitude of cases, even in cases where it was clear the debtor was desperate. (See for example, Roth v. ECMC and Abney v. U.S. Department of Education.)

Mr. Rhode has presented us with a very useful analysis of recent adversary proceedings against Navient and National Collegiate Student Loan Trust. A trend may be developing toward better bankruptcy outcomes for distressed student-loan debtors. Wouldn't that be a terrific development?




******

Out of curiosity I decided to take a look at recent bankruptcy Adversary Proceedings that had closed against Navient and National Collegiate Student Loan Trust. I looked at a number of cases and it appears people who filed their own Adversary Proceeding against their student loan holders had a less favorable outcome. Those people represented by an attorney, fair better.

At the very least, while the debt may not have been completely eliminated there were certainly some very deep discounts in the amount owed. Also the outcomes in all cases is not always apparent.

For example in Medina v. National Collegiate Student Loan Trust there was an apparent settlement agreement that contained a “release of liability. The Adversary Proceeding was then dismissed. – Source

Medina had asserted in his lawyer prepared complaint that his student loans should be discharged because his flight school was a “sham,” the loans were not used for a qualified educational purpose, and the school was not properly certified. These are issues raised over in this article. – Source

In the case Ard-Kelly v Sallie Mae the debtor owed $913,997 in loans. Of those loans all but $250,595 could be included in a $0 monthly Income Contingent Repayment plan. – Source

It appears all but $219,070 was found to be dischargeable in bankruptcy. While $219,070 is still a lot of money, it’s only 24% of the original balance stated. – Source

In Cotter v. Navient, the debtor had filed a Chapter 13 bankruptcy but was said to have still owed about $29,000 in student loan debt. Cotter stated, “Plaintiff incurred this student loan attending a school named ComputerTraining.com. The campus was located at 550 Polaris Parkway Westerville Ohio 43082. The Plaintiff started classes at said school on November 16, 2007 and was able to finish however the education he received was substandard, outdated and useless to him. Furthermore the school promised lifetime job placement assistance along with assistance with interviewing and resumes. The school he attended closed soon after he finished. The school in question is currently part of a class action lawsuit for fraud.” – Source

Following the court action regarding this debt the $29,000 balance was reduced to $2,500 with payments of $35.79 per month at 1% interest. This is about a 92% reduction in the amount owed. The debt will be fully repaid in 72 months. – Source

In Proctor v. Navient the debtor had co-signed for student loans for someone who was not a relative or dependent and said to not be qualified student loans protected in bankruptcy. – Source

The $188,787 balance was reduced to $15,535 at 3% interest and payments of $107.28 per month for 180 months. This is about a 92% reduction in the amount owed. – Source

So as you can see, recent closed bankruptcy Adversary Proceeding cases do result generally in some significant reductions in debt owed.

Steve Rhode
Get Out of Debt Guy
Twitter, G+, Facebook

This article by Steve Rhode first appeared on Get Out of Debt Guy and was distributed by the Personal Finance Syndication Network.

7 comments:

  1. Sounds good! Since you probably don't have a lot of cash laying around, you'll pay the debt settlement company a series of month to month payments. Credit Card Debt Relief Government

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is an excellent blog along with the great knowledge.
    Wordpress blog

    ReplyDelete
  3. Secured loans can be more hard to oversee when on the off chance that you wind up in a bad position. A secured loan may not be qualified for end on the off chance that you petition for bankruptcy.usafastloans.biz no credit verification payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  4. Individual loans online can be an advantageous method to get this sort of money related help.Lån

    ReplyDelete
  5. I love this. It is soo informative. Are you also searching for swedish assignment writers we are the best solution for you. We are best known for delivering the best services to students without having to break the bank

    ReplyDelete
  6. Pareeksha Bhavan, the office of the Commissioner for Government Examinations, Department of General Education, Govt. of Kerala is the institution Pareeksha Bhavan SSLC Book for conducting various Government examinations including SSLC,THSSLC,KGTE,K-TET,D.Ed/D.El.Ed,Scholarship exams etc. The Joint commissioner,the Secretary and other staff of the Pareekshabhaven assist the Commissioner in Examinations related activities.

    ReplyDelete
  7. For the users seeking unlimited plans for everything even on roaming, these BSNL combo prepaid tariffs introduced with a worth from Rupees 106 to 2999 allowing free mobile data and unlimited calling and free SMS facility is the best from the operator when compared to other operators, BSNL prepaid plans After a difficult couple of years, operator started the installation of 4G network and launched different unlimited BSNL recharge plans in the market with new tariff allowing many ways to activate BSNL validity recharge for voice and 4G data by introducing in support to 4G network as per the competition in each area by allowing all the plans through BSNL online recharge portal.

    ReplyDelete