Like many Americans, I have been surprised by the intensity of the Black-Lives-Matter protests that take place nightly in Portland, Oregon. Why Portland?
USA Today speculated yesterday that Oregon's racist past is fueling the city's protests. As the newspaper pointed out, Oregon's territorial constitution, adopted in 1857, barred people of color from entering Oregon Territory. And Oregon had a very active Ku Klux Klan during the early 1920s, as USA Today noted.
But I don't think Oregon's "dark history" of racism explains the violence in Portland's streets. Portland is, after all, one of the most progressive cities in America. US News and World Report recently listed Portland as one of the nation's top ten best cities.
And no one can accuse Portland's politicians of being racist. The city's progressive political scene is so famous that the television series Portlandia lampooned it for eight seasons.
Nor is Portland torn by racial strife. Portland is a mostly white city in a primarily white state. Only two percent of Oregon's population is Black, and only about one in twenty Portland residents is African American. Compare that ratio to Baton Rouge, where I live. My city is 52 percent African American, and no one is rioting.
Watching the Portland protests night after night, I have been struck by the fact that most of the protesters are young, white people. I find myself wondering whether these enraged wokesters have college degrees, whether they have good jobs, and whether they have student-loan debt.
We know that millions of Americans are burdened by student loans that hinder them from getting married, buying homes, or saving for retirement. And we know that a majority of these debtors are not paying down their loans. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos admitted as much almost two years ago.
I'm guessing that a lot of the people who are protesting on Portland's streets have student-loan debt that is completely unmanageable. Although the demonstrators may have college degrees, those degrees did not lead to good jobs for many of them.
I am not questioning the sincerity of people who have taken to the streets of Portland this summer. I am sure most of them are genuinely disturbed by racism and economic injustice.
But I wonder: How many people who are throwing bricks and bottles at the police would stay in their homes at night, munch on popcorn and watch a Netflix movie if they believed they were financially secure, had a good job, and were not weighed down by student loans.
|Portland protesters: most are young and white|
Post a Comment